Vegan Girlfriend Insists Boyfriend Rehome Cat, Faces Ultimatum

Falling head over heels in love often motivates individuals to make major lifestyle changes, such as quitting smoking, altering their diet, or refreshing their wardrobe. Yet, complications can arise when it comes to pets.
His girlfriend, a dedicated vegan, felt that owning a cat was at odds with her beliefs.
In his Reddit post, the man shared, “I’ve been with my GF for 7 months. She’s wonderful and we connect well in many aspects. She’s a passionate vegan and made it clear from the beginning that it was essential for her that her partner aligns with her cruelty-free values. Since I was a pescatarian, transitioning to a completely vegan diet was a breeze. My GF was thrilled that I adopted a cruelty-free lifestyle. We even became known as ‘the vegan couple’ at college.”
However, the issue regarding his cat Mittens remained unresolved. “I’ve had her for three years and cherish her deeply. She’s such a loving cat. My GF never felt at ease around her, saying it was because she wasn’t accustomed to cats. Eventually, we decided to primarily spend time at her place, and we stopped discussing Mittens.

Their bond became stronger during the pandemic, leading them to consider moving in together. That’s when his girlfriend urged him to part ways with Mittens, claiming that having a cat contradicted vegan principles since cats consume meat.
“I was taken aback,” he shared. “I told her I couldn’t let go of Mittens. I explained that I reduced harm by selecting reputable cat food brands. Numerous vegans have cats and share this perspective. My girlfriend became upset and asked, ‘How much meat does your cat consume? How many animals had to die for that food? Would you be okay if it were human meat?’”
Feeling distressed, he left her place. Once home, he snuggled with Mittens, but his spirits sank when his girlfriend sent him a link to a Reddit discussion suggesting that domestic cats should be eradicated.
He wrapped up his post by stating, “It’s evident I’m not parting with my cat. It’s disheartening to think that a wonderful relationship could end over differing beliefs. I don’t completely understand my girlfriend’s viewpoint since many vegans have cats.”
Later, he updated his post on r/relationship_advice, explaining that his girlfriend’s extreme opinions on cats were not representative of most vegans or vegetarians. “New vegans can sometimes be overly zealous. Most of us simply strive to avoid harming animals,” he remarked.
He also mentioned that they had ended their relationship. “I would never part with Mittens,” he asserted. Looking back on the relationship, he recognized that it was more about control than veganism. He noted a recurring pattern of controlling behavior from his girlfriend.
Ultimately, he felt that breaking up was the right choice given their relationship challenges. Would you have made the same decision?



